Subconsciously, web browsing opens up a world of styles and impressions. To some of those styles we are used to, but often it is just unfamiliar language, new images and experiences. Does it matter that we read text, information, entertainment written in style (and language) that is not our own ? The current debate both in academia and the real world about the negative effects of the internet on political polarization are well known. The arguments circle around overt features of communication, social networks and outright misinformation. What is often overlooked though is the impressionistic richness of our online lives. This online field experiment / project tests predictions on the effect of style on 1) biased reasoning and 2) political fragmentation. Our conjecture is the idea that unfamiliar style makes us actually more realistic about power and the need for compromise. Using online field experiments, we provide evidence that diverse style, as opposed to diverse content, can enhance contrasting and political realism.